I pride myself on being a brutal realist when it comes to GMAT tutoring. If I think that I can't help somebody improve his GMAT score, I immediately tell him. If a student isn't doing her homework, I'll tell her to stop wasting her money on a tutor. If I think that a student can't possibly achieve his GMAT goal, I'll find a polite way to say so. And if I make a mistake, I'll admit it immediately. I'm not really into hiding.
I've had a surprising number of hits on my original post about Mr. V, one of my students here in NYC who has worked like crazy to raise his score. Basically, he's seen every single useful GMAT question at least twice. He took the exam twice, and couldn't crack 640. I've tutored him for the past six weeks, and I was absolutely convinced that he'd made some great progress. He was nailing some of my toughest math and sentence correction questions, he was holding his own on the LSAT material, and his final GMATPrep test was well into the 700s.
It took some creativity to put together a good program for him, and I thought that I'd be able to write a gloating post about how well my odd schemes worked. Unfortunately, nothing worked as well as we'd planned. Mr. V took the GMAT last weekend, and his verbal score actually went down. I was pretty shocked and humbled by that. I thought that we had really made him better, and it just didn't happen. His math score improved, but his composite score went sideways.
Mr. V has been more than gracious, and doesn't blame me at all for his lack of improvement. (Actually, he posted a glowing endorsement of me on his blog. Thank you for that, good sir.) But I can't help but feel a little bit responsible. Sometimes, even a dedicated tutor's best efforts just don't quite cut it, and I don't want to run from that fact.
For what it's worth, Mr. V didn't see anything surprising on the exam. He said that it was pretty much exactly what he expected: the critical reasoning and reading comprehension were hard but reasonable, the math was predictably tough, and the sentence correction didn't contain any grammatical surprises. If anything, we suspected that the sentence correction idioms got the best of him--he said that he was unsure whether he chose the right phrases on a number of questions. That, coupled with a little bit of bad luck, probably did the damage on the verbal section. And unfortunately, I didn't advise him to memorize hundreds of idioms before taking the GMAT. (Nor would I ever recommend memorizing more than a few dozen of the most frequently used idioms.)
Unless Mr. V suddenly gets shy and asks me to stop, I'll continue posting occasionally about his progress with his MBA quest. He has chosen not to re-take the test, but we'll keep working together in an effort to make his MBA applications sing. The point of all of his GMAT labors was to get into a great MBA program. And if he can pull that off, the disappointment of the score won't really matter at all.